* Bold records denote winners
| Award Year | Award Category | Title | Author's Name | Publisher/Producer | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1962 | Best Play | Write Me a Murder | Frederick Knott | ||
| 1962 | Best Play | A Shot in the Dark | Harry Kurnitz | ||
| 1962 | Best Short Story | Affair at Lahore Cantonment | Avram Davidson | Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine | Volume: June '61 |
| 1962 | Best Short Story | Ellery Queen 1962 Anthology | Ellery Queen | Davis Publications | Volume: '61 |
| 1962 | Best Short Story | The Children of Alda Nuova | Robert Wallston | Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine | Volume: August '61 |
| 1962 | Book Jacket Award | Walker & Company | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1962 | Book Jacket Award | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1962 | Book Jacket Award | Harper Bros. | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1962 | Special Edgars | The Annals of Murder | Thomas M. McDade | University of Oklahoma Press | |
| 1962 | The Grand Master | Erle Stanley Gardner | |||
| 1962 | The Raven Award | The Defenders | Comment: a TV show in its first year | ||
| 1961 | Best Episode in a TV Series | The Case of the Burning Court | Kelley Roos | NBC-TV | Series: Dow Hour of Great Mysteries |
| 1961 | Best Episode in a TV Series | The Day of the Bullet | Bill Ballinger | NBC-TV | Series: Alfred Hitchcock Presents |
| 1961 | Best Fact Crime | The Overbury Affair | Miriam Allen deFord | Chilton | |
| 1961 | Best Fact Crime | Heaven Knows Who | Christianna Brand | Scribners | |
| 1961 | Best Fact Crime | Mostly Murder | Sir Sydney Smith | McKay | |
| 1961 | Best First Novel | The Man in the Cage | John Holbrooke Vance | Random House | |
| 1961 | Best First Novel | Case Pending | Dell Shannon | Harper | |
| 1961 | Best First Novel | The Killing at Big Tree | David McCarthy | Doubleday | |
| 1961 | Best First Novel | The Marriage Cage | William Johnston | Lyle Stuart | |
| 1961 | Best First Novel | The Mercenaries | Donald E. Westlake | Random House | |
| 1961 | Best Juvenile | The Mystery of the Haunted Pool | Phyllis A. Whitney | Westminster Press | |
| 1961 | Best Motion Picture | Psycho | Robert Bloch, Joseph Stefano | Paramount | Comment: a Scroll to Bloch as the book writer, Stefano is the screenwriter |
| 1961 | Best Novel | The Progress of a Crime | Julian Symons | Harper | |
| 1961 | Best Novel | The Devil's Own | Peter Curtis | Doubleday | |
| 1961 | Best Novel | The Traces of Brillhart | Herbert Brean | Harper | |
| 1961 | Best Novel | Watcher in the Shadows | Geoffrey Household | Little, Brown | |
| 1961 | Best Short Story | Tiger | John Durham | Cosmopolitan | Volume: February '60 |
| 1961 | Best Short Story | A Real Live Murder | Donald Honig | Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine | Volume: October '60 |
| 1961 | Best Short Story | A View From the Terrace | Mike Marmer | Cosmopolitan | Volume: December '60 |
| 1961 | Best Short Story | Louisa, Please | Shirley Jackson | Ladies' Home Journal | Volume: February '60 |
| 1961 | Best Short Story | Summer Evil | Nora Kaplan | Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine | Volume: October '60 |
| 1961 | Book Jacket Award | A Mark of Displeasure | Scribners | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1961 | Book Jacket Award | The Three Coffins | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1961 | Outstanding Mystery Criticism | James Sandoe | New York Herald-Tribune | ||
| 1961 | Special Edgars | Charles Addams | Comment: cartooinst of the macabre | ||
| 1961 | Special Edgars | Elizabeth Daly | Comment: grande dame of women mystery writers | ||
| 1961 | Special Edgars | Philip Wittenberg | Comment: legal counsel | ||
| 1961 | The Grand Master | Ellery Queen | Comment: AKA: Frederic Dannay and Manfred B. Lee | ||
| 1961 | The Raven Award | Ilka Chase | Comment: Reader of the Year | ||
| 1960 | Best Episode in a TV Series | The Empty Chair | David Karp | ABC | Series: The Untouchables |
| 1960 | Best Episode in a TV Series | The Comic | Blake Edwards | NBC-TV | |
| 1960 | Best Fact Crime | Fire at Sea | Thomas Gallager | Rhinehart | |
| 1960 | Best Fact Crime | Great Train Robberies of the West | Eugene B. Block | Coward-McCann | |
| 1960 | Best First Novel | The Grey Flannel Shroud | Henry Slesar | Random House | |
| 1960 | Best First Novel | A Dream of Falling | Mary O. Rank | Houghton Mifflin | |
| 1960 | Best Foreign film | Sapphire | Janet Green | Rank/Artna | |
| 1960 | Best Motion Picture | North by Northwest | Ernest Lehman | MGM | |
| 1960 | Best Novel | The Hours Before Dawn | Celia Fremlin | Lippincott | |
| 1960 | Best Novel | The List of Adrian Messenger | Philip MacDonald | Doubleday | |
| 1960 | Best Radio Drama | Sorry, Wrong Number | Lucille Fletcher | CBS | Series: Suspense |
| 1960 | Best Radio Drama | 1959 Suspense | William N. Robson | CBS | Comment: Raven Award |
| 1960 | Best Short Story | The Landlady | Roald Dahl | The New Yorker | Volume: November '59 |
| 1960 | Best Short Story | The Day of the Bullet | Stanley Ellin | Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine | Volume: October '59 |
| 1960 | The Raven Award | Ray Brennan | Comment: for crime reporting | ||
| 1960 | The Raven Award | David C. Cook | Comment: for Best Detective Stories of the Year | ||
| 1960 | The Raven Award | Alfred Hitchcock | Comment: for his contribution to the mystery genre | ||
| 1960 | The Raven Award | Gail Jackson | Comment: producer of Perry Mason TV series | ||
| 1960 | The Raven Award | Phyllis McGinley | Comment: Mystery Fan of the Year | ||
| 1959 | Best Episode in a TV Series | Capital Punishment | James Lee | NBC-TV | Series: Omnibus |
| 1959 | Best Episode in a TV Series | The Edge of Truth | Adrian Spies | CBS-TV | Series: Studio One |
| 1959 | Best Fact Crime | They Died in the Chair | Wenzell Brown | Popular Library | |
| 1959 | Best Fact Crime | The Deadly Reasons | Edward D. Radin | Popular Library | |
| 1959 | Best Fact Crime | The Incurable Wound | Berton Roueche | Little, Brown | |
| 1959 | Best Fact Crime | The Murder and the Trial | Edgar Lustgarten | Scribners | |
| 1959 | Best Fact Crime | The Royal Vultures | Hillel Black | Pocket Books | Comment: as told by Sam Kollman |
| 1959 | Best First Novel | The Bright Road to Fear | Richard Martin Stern | Ballantine | |
| 1959 | Best First Novel | Death of a Spinster | Frances Duncombe | Scribners | |
| 1959 | Best First Novel | Now Will You Try for Murder? | Harry Olesker | Simon & Schuster | |
| 1959 | Best First Novel | The Man Who Disappeared | Edgar J. Bohle | Random House | |
| 1959 | Best Foreign film | Inspector Maigret | Georges Simenon | Intermondia/J.P. Guibert/Jolly Film | |
| 1959 | Best Motion Picture | The Defiant Ones | Nathan E. Douglas, Harold Jacob Smith | United Artists | |
| 1959 | Best Novel | The Eighth Circle | Stanley Ellin | Random House | |
| 1959 | Best Novel | A Gentleman Called | Dorothy Salisbury Davis | Scribners | |
| 1959 | Best Novel | The Madhouse in Washington Square | David Alexander | Lippincott | |
| 1959 | Best Novel | The Woman in the Woods | Lee Blackstock | Doubleday | |
| 1959 | Best Short Story | Over There, Darkness | William O'Farrell | Sleuth | Volume: October '58 |
| 1959 | Book Jacket Award | Western Printing & Lithographing Co. | Comment: for Dell book jackets | ||
| 1959 | Special Edgars | American Murder Ballads | Olive Wooley Burt | Oxford University Press | |
| 1959 | The Grand Master | Rex Stout | |||
| 1959 | The Raven Award | Lawrence G. Blochman | Comment: for long and distinguished service to MWA and The Third Degree | ||
| 1959 | The Raven Award | Frederic G. Melcher | Comment: on his retirement after 35 years with Publishers Weekly | ||
| 1959 | The Raven Award | Franklin Delano Roosevelt | Comment: (posthumous) Reader of the Year, accepted by Eleanor Roosevelt | ||
| 1958 | Best First Novel | Root of Evil | James Cross | Messner | |
| 1958 | Best Motion Picture | Twelve Angry Men | Reginald Rose | Orion/Nova | |
| 1958 | Best Motion Picture | Witness for the Prosecution | Harry Kurnitz, Billy Wilder | United Artists | |
| 1958 | Best Novel | Room to Swing | Ed Lacy | Harper | |
| 1958 | Best Novel | The Bushman Who Came Back | Arthur Upfield | Doubleday | |
| 1958 | Best Novel | The Longest Second | Bill Ballinger | Harper | |
| 1958 | Best Novel | The Night of the Good Children | Marjorie Carleton | Wm. Morrow | |
| 1958 | Best Radio Drama | The Galindez-Murphy Case: A Chronicle of Terror | Jay MacMullen | CBS | |
| 1958 | Best Short Story | The Secret of the Bottle | Gerald Kersh | Saturday Evening Post | Volume: December 7 '57 |
| 1958 | Best Short Story | And Already Lost | Charlotte Armstrong | Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine | Volume: June '57 |
| 1958 | Book Jacket Award | Harper Bros. | Comment: for general excellence | ||
| 1958 | Book Jacket Award | Dell | Comment: for their Great Mystery Series book jackets | ||
| 1958 | The Grand Master | Vincent Starrett | |||
| 1958 | Best Episode in a TV Series | Mechanical Manhunt | Harold Swanton | NBC-TV | Series: Alcoa Hour |
| 1958 | Best Episode in a TV Series | The Trial of Lizzie Borden | Omnibus staff | ABC | Series: Omnibus |
| 1958 | Best Fact Crime | The D.A.'s Man | Harold R. Danforth, James D. Horan | Crown | |
| 1958 | Best Fact Crime | Memoirs of a Bow Street Runner | Henry Goddard, Patrick Pringle | Wm. Morrow |