* Bold records denote winners
| Award Year | Award Category | Title | Author's Name | Publisher/Producer | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | Tales of the Black Widowers | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | The Hubschmann Effect | Pocket Books | Comment: softcover | |
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | Anima | Fawcett-Crest | Comment: softcover | |
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | Feral | Harper & Row | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | Nella Waits | Putnam | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | The Mousetrap | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1975 | Book Jacket Award | They Can't Hang Me | Harper & Row | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1974 | Book Jacket Award | Reprisal | Dodd, Mead | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1974 | Book Jacket Award | The Abductor | Curtis Books | Comment: softcover | |
| 1974 | Book Jacket Award | Daughter of Darkness | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1974 | Book Jacket Award | Hail to the Chief | Random House | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1974 | Book Jacket Award | Inspector Maigret and the Madwoman | Curtis Books | Comment: softcover | |
| 1974 | Book Jacket Award | The Cold Ones | Simon & Schuster | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | Fetish Murders | Ace | Comment: softcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | The Erection Set | E.P. Dutton | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | Dead Skip | Random House | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | Death can Be Beautiful | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | Mrs. Knox's Profession | McKay | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | Rolling Gravestones | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1973 | Book Jacket Award | Tricks of the Trade | G.P. Putnam's Sons | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1972 | Book Jacket Award | Black Man, White Man | Ace | Comment: softcover | |
| 1972 | Book Jacket Award | If You Want to See Your Wife Again | G.P. Putnam's Sons | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1972 | Book Jacket Award | The Lady of the Lake | Ballantine | Comment: softcover | |
| 1972 | Book Jacket Award | The Shadows of the House | Avon | Comment: softcover | |
| 1972 | Book Jacket Award | The Stalker | Random House | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1972 | Book Jacket Award | Whim to Kill | William Morrow | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1971 | Book Jacket Award | Act of Violence | Dodd, Mead | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1971 | Book Jacket Award | Last Case | Avon | Comment: softcover; Series: Classic Crime Collection | |
| 1971 | Book Jacket Award | If Laurel Shot Hardy the World Would End | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1971 | Book Jacket Award | If the Shroud Fits | Inner Sanctum | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1971 | Book Jacket Award | One Man Show | Avon | Comment: softcover | |
| 1971 | Book Jacket Award | Picture Miss Seeton | Popular Library | Comment: softcover | |
| 1970 | Book Jacket Award | Classic Crime Collection | Avon | Comment: softcover | |
| 1970 | Book Jacket Award | The Spanish Prisoner | E.P. Dutton | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1970 | Book Jacket Award | Tales of Unease | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1970 | Book Jacket Award | The Black General | Wm. Morrow | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1969 | Book Jacket Award | God Speed the Night | Scribners | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1969 | Book Jacket Award | Nothing Is the Number When You Die | Ballantine | Comment: softcover | |
| 1969 | Book Jacket Award | The Dresden Green | Ballantine | Comment: softcover | |
| 1969 | Book Jacket Award | A Tangled Web | Berkley | Comment: softcover | |
| 1969 | Book Jacket Award | Die Quickly, Dear Mother | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1969 | Book Jacket Award | Singapore Wink | Wm. Morrow | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1968 | Book Jacket Award | Johnny Underground | Ballantine | Comment: softcover | |
| 1968 | Book Jacket Award | Malice Matrimonial | Ballantine | Comment: softcover | |
| 1968 | Book Jacket Award | Perturbing Spirit | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1968 | Book Jacket Award | A Doll for the Toff | Pyramid | Comment: softcover | |
| 1968 | Book Jacket Award | Rain with Violence | A.A. Mills | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1968 | Book Jacket Award | The Reluctant Medium | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | I Am the Cat | Collier | Comment: softcover | |
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | The Baron and the Mogul Swords | Scribners | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | The Crimson Madness of Little Doom | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | Crowell-Collier | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | Let Sleeping Girls Lie | Wm. Morrow | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | Some of Your Blood | Ballantine | Comment: softcover | |
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | Harper & Row | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1967 | Book Jacket Award | Bantam | |||
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Random House | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Girl on the Run | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Knock and Wait a While | Bantam | Comment: softcover | |
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Simon & Schuster | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Viking | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Dell | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1966 | Book Jacket Award | Popular Library | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1965 | Book Jacket Award | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1965 | Book Jacket Award | Walker & Company | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1965 | Book Jacket Award | Bantam | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1965 | Book Jacket Award | Dell | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1965 | Book Jacket Award | Popular Library | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1965 | Book Jacket Award | Inner Sanctum Mysteries | Simon & Schuster | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1964 | Book Jacket Award | Harper & Row | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1964 | Book Jacket Award | Simon & Schuster | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1964 | Book Jacket Award | Berkley | Comment: softcover; Series: Medallion Books | ||
| 1964 | Book Jacket Award | Popular Library | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1963 | Book Jacket Award | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1963 | Book Jacket Award | Collier | Comment: softcover | ||
| 1962 | Book Jacket Award | Walker & Company | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1962 | Book Jacket Award | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1962 | Book Jacket Award | Harper Bros. | Comment: hardcover | ||
| 1961 | Book Jacket Award | A Mark of Displeasure | Scribners | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1961 | Book Jacket Award | The Three Coffins | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1959 | Book Jacket Award | Western Printing & Lithographing Co. | Comment: for Dell book jackets | ||
| 1958 | Book Jacket Award | Harper Bros. | Comment: for general excellence | ||
| 1958 | Book Jacket Award | Dell | Comment: for their Great Mystery Series book jackets | ||
| 1957 | Book Jacket Award | Inspector Maigret and the Burglar's Wife | Doubleday | Comment: hardcover | |
| 1956 | Book Jacket Award | Scribners | |||
| 1955 | Book Jacket Award | Berton Roueche | Dell | Comment: softcover | |
| 1955 | Book Jacket Award | Eleven Blue Men | Little, Brown |