* Bold records denote winners
| Award Year | Award Category | Title | Author's Name | Publisher/Producer | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1960 | Best Radio Drama | Sorry, Wrong Number | Lucille Fletcher | CBS | Series: Suspense |
| 1960 | Best Radio Drama | 1959 Suspense | William N. Robson | CBS | Comment: Raven Award |
| 1958 | Best Radio Drama | The Galindez-Murphy Case: A Chronicle of Terror | Jay MacMullen | CBS | |
| 1955 | Best Radio Drama | The Tree | Stanley Niss | CBS | Series: 21st Precinct |
| 1954 | Best Radio Drama | The Shot | E. Jack Neuman | CBS | Series: Suspense |
| 1953 | Best Radio Drama | The Mysterious Traveler | Robert Arthur, David Kogan | Mutual Broadcasting System | |
| 1952 | Best Radio Drama | Dragnet | James Moser, Jack Webb | NBC | |
| 1951 | Best Radio Drama | Dragnet | James Moser, Jack Webb | NBC | |
| 1951 | Best Radio Drama | The Mysterious Traveler | Robert Arthur, David Kogan | Mutual Broadcasting System | |
| 1950 | Best Radio Drama | Murder by Experts | Robert Arthur, David Kogan | Mutual Broadcasting System | |
| 1950 | Best Radio Drama | Suspense | unknown | CBS | |
| 1950 | Best Radio Drama | The Fat Man | unknown | ABC | |
| 1950 | Best Radio Drama | This is Your FBI | unknown | ABC | |
| 1949 | Best Radio Drama | Inner Sanctum | John Roeburt | CBS | Comment: Himan Brown director/producer |
| 1949 | Best Radio Drama | The Mysterious Traveler | Robert Arthur, David Kogan | Mutual Broadcasting System | |
| 1948 | Best Radio Drama | Suspense | William Spier | CBS | |
| 1947 | Best Radio Drama | The Adventures of Sam Spade | Jason James, Bob Tallman | CBS | Comment: William Spier producer |
| 1946 | Best Radio Drama | Ellery Queen | Frederic Dannay, Manfred B. Lee | CBS | Comment: A tie this year with MR. AND MRS. NORTH, Dannay and Lee were the team using the pseudonym "Ellery Queen" |
| 1946 | Best Radio Drama | Mr. and Mrs. North | Frances Lockridge, Richard Lockridge | NBC | Comment: A tie this year with ELLERY QUEEN |